In recent years, diamond jewelry has become more accessible, no longer exclusive to the affluent. Thanks to online shops, you can now acquire stunning diamonds without straining your finances.
However, purchasing a new diamond isn’t always the optimal choice. Sometimes, the ideal solution lies in transforming something old into something fresh.
If you’re wondering, “Can I give my diamond a new setting?” – the answer is a resounding yes!
Resetting a diamond presents a fantastic alternative to buying an entirely new jewelry piece. By doing so, not only do you preserve the sentimental value attached to the diamond, but you also provide a boost to your wallet. Typically, acquiring a new diamond setting costs significantly less than purchasing a new stone.
Moreover, you have the opportunity to revamp your diamond ring, earrings, necklace, or any other jewelry item, breathing new life into its appearance.
When it comes to redesigning your diamond, the possibilities are abundant. You can opt for a simple change in the setting or explore options like adding additional stones. This article will provide you with comprehensive insights into the process of obtaining a new setting for your diamond.
DESIGN YOUR OWN ENGAGEMENT RING: START WITH A SETTING OR START WITH A DIAMOND. IT’S REALLY UP TO YOU!

Reasons To Get A New Setting
Deciding to reset your diamond can be a challenging decision, especially if it holds sentimental value or has been a cherished gift. You may feel hesitant to make changes out of guilt or a sense of ingratitude.
However, it’s essential not to remain attached to a setting you don’t love purely out of obligation. Resetting a diamond is an opportunity for an upgrade that will make your cherished piece shine like new.
There are several common reasons why people choose to opt for a new setting for their diamond. Let’s explore them in detail:
- Wear and Tear: While diamonds are durable, the setting can deteriorate over time. Prongs may become loose or even chip, risking the loss of the center diamond or surrounding smaller stones. If your setting has experienced significant damage or stone loss, resetting becomes a practical choice.
- Anniversary: Many individuals choose to reset their engagement rings or other jewelry pieces to commemorate significant anniversaries, such as 10 or 25 years of a relationship. It’s a way to celebrate milestones and mark the growth and success of your partnership.
- Refreshing the Old: While diamonds are timeless, settings can become outdated. If you’ve inherited a diamond with a style that doesn’t align with your taste or preferences, resetting it can breathe new life into the piece. Transforming an inherited piece into a design that resonates with your personal style ensures the diamond doesn’t remain neglected or tucked away in a jewelry box.
- Letting Go of the Past: Jewelry often carries sentimental value, which may not always be associated with positive memories. Resetting jewelry after a divorce, the end of a friendship, or during a period that holds negative associations allows you to create a fresh start. The new setting becomes a symbol of growth and resilience, helping you embrace the positive memories while leaving behind the past.
- Seeking a New Style: Sometimes, the desire for change is reason enough to reset a diamond. If you no longer resonate with the style of the current setting, regardless of who purchased it or the occasion, it’s an opportunity to explore new designs that reflect your current fashion sense and personality. Whether you opt for an existing design or create a custom piece, the possibilities for resetting are vast.
Remember, resetting a diamond allows you to revitalize its appearance while preserving its sentimental value. It’s a way to enjoy and cherish your beautiful diamond in a way that aligns with your current preferences and lifestyle.

Reasons Not To Get A New Setting
There are few reasons why you should hesitate to get a new setting for your diamond. The most common concerns revolve around feelings of guilt or nostalgia, particularly when the diamond holds sentimental value as a gift from a loved one.
Resetting your diamond should be an exciting and joyful experience, akin to the joy of acquiring a new diamond. If the thought of resetting only evokes negative emotions or brings about feelings of guilt, it may not be the best choice for you at this moment.
Perhaps you’re not ready to let go of the past or worry about disappointing your family with your decision. It’s important to remember that resetting can always be postponed, and there’s no rush to make a decision. Take the time to carefully consider your options and proceed with resetting only when you feel confident and certain that it’s the right choice for you.

How Much Does It Cost To Put Diamonds In A New Setting?
Resetting a diamond is generally a cost-effective option compared to purchasing a new diamond. However, the price can vary depending on the specific changes you want to make to the setting.
The cost of labor for resetting a diamond typically ranges from $100 to $500, depending on the size of the diamond. This cost is in addition to the materials required for the new setting. If you desire significant changes or additions, such as additional stones, the price can reach $5,000 or more.
Several factors influence the final price of a new diamond setting, including:
- The type of metal used for the setting, such as gold, white gold, silver, or platinum.
- The inclusion of additional stones in the setting.
- The color of the stones being added.
- The size of your diamond.
- The complexity of the new setting design.
- The need for a recut of the diamond.
When resetting your diamond, you have the option to choose from pre-made settings or create a custom design.
Pre-made settings are typically more affordable as they are already constructed, requiring the jeweler to simply place the diamond into the setting. There is a wide range of pre-made settings available, making it highly likely that you will find one you like. However, if you prefer a more personalized touch, a custom-made setting may be the better choice.
Custom-made settings have a higher price due to the additional cost of designing the setting. The material and labor costs remain the same as with pre-made settings. You can either develop the design yourself or collaborate with a jeweler who can assist you. Many jewelers use computer-aided design (CAD) software to create the design, as it allows for easier modifications compared to handcrafted models.

Where To Reset Your Diamond?
Resetting a diamond is a commonly offered service by many jewelers, but not all jewelers possess the same level of skill and trustworthiness. It is essential to select a reputable jeweler with years of experience when considering resetting your diamond.
One potential risk during the resetting process is the possibility of chipping off the edges of the diamond, particularly with cuts like princess, marquise, pear, and emerald cuts that have more vulnerable corners. To mitigate this risk, most jewelers have insurance coverage for potential stone damage or loss while the diamond is in their possession. It is advisable to obtain insurance and a certificate for your diamond before proceeding with resetting to protect against potential scams. Additionally, if you have concerns, you can request to be present during the resetting process.
While most jewelers prioritize their reputation and strive to deliver excellent results, it is always wise to exercise caution. A reputable professional will have positive reviews, recommendations, and examples of their previous work.
It is important to note that not every jeweler may be willing to reset your diamond, depending on the diamond itself and where it was originally purchased. If a jeweler believes there is a high risk of damaging the diamond during resetting, they may decline the job to safeguard their reputation. Additionally, if the profit margin for resetting is minimal compared to the cost of new jewelry, some jewelers may only offer the service to customers who purchased the original piece from their store.
The duration of the diamond reset process typically ranges from three to six weeks. The exact timeline depends on the jeweler and the complexity of the desired setting. Custom designs and intricate settings with additional stones will require more time compared to simple pre-made designs. To expedite the process, having a clear idea of your desired outcome without making changes along the way is beneficial, although some waiting time is inevitable.

How To Choose A New Setting?
If you have made the decision to get a new setting for your diamond but are unsure about the design, we have some inspiration for you. In this section, we will explore the most common upgrades for diamond settings to help you create your own unique design.
Diamond Accents
Adding diamond accents on the side of the center stone is a subtle yet beautiful change. These smaller diamonds will enhance the appearance of the central stone and add extra sparkle to your jewelry.
Diamond accents create a stunning visual effect when there is a contrast between the side stones and the center stone. Combining fancy colored diamonds with colorless diamonds can bring out the best of both worlds.
Placing a colorless diamond between two fancy colored diamonds will make the center stone look clearer and shinier. Similarly, a fancy colored diamond will appear more vibrant when surrounded by colorless diamonds.
More Diamonds
Sometimes, one diamond alone may not achieve the desired effect, regardless of its beauty. Adding more diamonds to the setting will make your jewelry truly stand out.
The size of the additional diamonds depends on how much you want your diamond to be the center of attention. If you wish to highlight the existing diamond, introducing small or medium-sized diamonds to the setting is recommended.
Alternatively, you can choose stones of the same size as your diamond but with different colors or cuts. This will make your diamond stand out and attract attention in a unique way.
Halo Setting
A halo setting involves surrounding the center stone with a cluster of tiny stones, creating a halo effect. This is a popular choice for resetting and enhancing the appearance of the center stone.
The small diamonds in the halo setting can make the center stone appear larger, more brilliant, and clearer, regardless of its clarity. This setting also works well with fancy colored diamonds, as the halo of tiny stones brings out the beauty of their color.
Larger Center Stone
While you may not initially consider buying a new gemstone when thinking about resetting your diamond, a larger center stone can be an ideal choice, especially for celebrating significant achievements or anniversaries.
You have the option to resell the old diamond and purchase a new, larger one for your existing setting. Alternatively, you can incorporate the old diamond into the new design by adding a larger center stone alongside it.
Remember, these ideas are meant to inspire you. Feel free to explore different combinations and styles to create a new diamond setting that perfectly suits your taste and celebrates your unique story.

Conclusion
A new diamond setting has the power to transform both you and your diamond. When you place an old diamond in a fresh setting, it breathes new life into the piece of jewelry, perfectly aligned with your personal style. The best part is that this upgrade is relatively affordable compared to purchasing a completely new diamond.
With numerous options available for the new diamond setting, take your time in making your decision. Feel free to explore different designs and don’t hesitate to seek guidance from a skilled jeweler.
Enjoy the process of designing your new setting, just as you would enjoy selecting a new diamond. Let your creativity soar and have fun with this exciting endeavor.
We trust that this article has addressed your question, “Can I Get a New Setting for Diamond?” and has provided valuable insights to inspire your vision for the perfect diamond setting.